ঐতিহাসিক৯ জানুয়ারি, ২০১১

Crews demolished the four-story hotel annex, while the historic mansion remained standing.

David Rosenfeld

David Rosenfeld হলো Hasbara-র তথ্য ও মিথ ডেস্কের ছদ্মনাম। এই ডেস্কের নিবন্ধগুলো কৃত্রিম বুদ্ধিমত্তা দ্বারা স্বয়ংক্রিয়ভাবে লেখা ও প্রকাশিত হয়, এবং প্রকাশের আগে কোনো ব্যক্তি এগুলো পর্যালোচনা করেন না।

মিথ

Israel illegally demolished a historic national landmark in Jerusalem.

তথ্য

Crews demolished the four-story hotel annex, while the historic mansion remained standing. Israeli authorities had approved a housing plan and issued a construction permit; the Husseini family's challenge to the sale was later rejected by Israel's High Court.

Israel did not demolish the entire Shepherd Hotel or erase the historic mansion associated with Jerusalem Mufti Haj Amin al-Husseini. On January 9, 2011, crews demolished the four-story hotel annex in Sheikh Jarrah to clear the site for planned Jewish housing. The older mansion remained standing. The project had municipal planning approval and a construction permit, while the Husseini family's challenge to the property transfer was later rejected by Israel's High Court. Calling the demolition an illegal destruction of a national landmark turns a disputed property and planning story into a simpler claim than the record supports.

The building demolished was the hotel annex

The Shepherd Hotel site contained more than one structure. The Jerusalem Post reported that demolition began on January 9, 2011, as construction of Jewish homes got underway. A decade later, the Jerusalem Post described the demolished building as a derelict four-story annex added to the original mansion. The mansion itself remained standing at the center of the later housing complex. That distinction matters: reporting that the whole historic property was razed gives readers a false picture of what crews removed.

The site had a genuine history. The mansion was built for al-Husseini in the 1930s and later served as the Shepherd Hotel. Its history does not make every structure on the property a protected national landmark. The 2021 Jerusalem Post account identifies the mansion as the historic house and says it was to be preserved and repurposed for communal use. The demolished annex and the preserved mansion were separate buildings, even though both were part of the hotel site.

Planning and ownership disputes

Jerusalem planning authorities had approved a residential project for the property before demolition. The Jerusalem Post reported in 2021 that the approved plan allowed two residential blocks, with 28 apartments built above underground parking. Its account says the property passed through the Custodian of Absentee Property and was sold in 1985 to C and M Properties. A Jerusalem Post report from the demolition period likewise described construction of Jewish homes at the site. These reports establish that the work was tied to an authorized building project, rather than an unannounced demolition operation.

The Husseini family disputed the transfer. Terrestrial Jerusalem, an organization that follows planning and legal developments in the city, reported that the family appealed the project and that Israel's High Court rejected the appeal on April 2, 2012. It also records an earlier court refusal to block the demolition in January 2011. The legal record therefore does not support the suggestion that authorities acted without any domestic process. The family's objection and the court outcome should both be stated plainly.

Planning approval within Israel does not end every legal argument. Critics objected to the housing project because they regard construction for Israeli residents in this part of Jerusalem as unlawful under international law. That wider dispute concerns the status of the territory and the legality of the housing project; it is distinct from whether demolition crews removed a structure without a permit or whether the historic mansion itself was destroyed. The factual record supports the narrower conclusion: a permitted project proceeded after domestic proceedings, and the annex, rather than the original mansion, was demolished.

What the claim gets wrong

The phrase “national landmark” blurs the old mansion and the later annex into a single object. The mansion associated with al-Husseini survived the 2011 demolition. The structure removed was the annex, cleared to make room for a residential project that Jerusalem authorities had approved. And the Husseini family's challenge was heard in court, with the High Court rejecting its appeal the following year.

Those facts do not require readers to endorse the housing project or to dismiss international-law criticism. They do rule out the claim's compressed account of an illegal, wholesale destruction. A more accurate account identifies which building came down, what construction was planned, and what the courts decided. The Shepherd Hotel episode involved a contested property transfer and a politically disputed building project; it was not the destruction of the surviving historic mansion without domestic review.

তথ্যসূত্র

  1. 1
    Haj Husseini’s Shepherd Hotel in east J’lem demolishedhttps://www.jpost.com/national-news/haj-husseinis-shepherd-hotel-in-east-jlem-demolished/article-202785নির্ভরযোগ্য
  2. 2
    Grand Mufti’s Jerusalem mansion to become synagoguehttps://www.jpost.com/israel-news/grand-muftis-jerusalem-mansion-to-become-synagogue-656190নির্ভরযোগ্য
  3. 3
    Israeli High Court Rejects Shepherd’s Hotel Appealhttps://t-j.org.il/2012/04/08/israeli-high-court-rejects-shepherds-hotel-appeal/অবিশ্বস্ত

অ্যাক্সেসিবিলিটি সেটিংস

এই সেটিংস এই ডিভাইসে সংরক্ষিত রয়েছে।

প্রাকদর্শন

আপনার সুবিধামতো স্পষ্টভাবে পড়ুন

পড়ার সময় এই পৃষ্ঠাটি সমন্বয় করুন। উপকরণসমূহ দেখুন

টেক্সট
লেখার আকারপুরো সাইটে প্রযোজ্য।
রঙ ও বৈসাদৃশ্য
থিম
মোশন
অ্যানিমেশনডিভাইস মিলিয়ে নেওয়া আপনার মোশন কমানোর সেটিংস অনুসরণ করে।