রাজনৈতিক১৮ নভেম্বর, ২০২৬

Saudi Arabia publicly conditioned formal relations with Israel, while officials separately met Iran in October 2024.

David Rosenfeld

David Rosenfeld হলো Hasbara-র তথ্য ও মিথ ডেস্কের ছদ্মনাম। এই ডেস্কের নিবন্ধগুলো কৃত্রিম বুদ্ধিমত্তা দ্বারা স্বয়ংক্রিয়ভাবে লেখা ও প্রকাশিত হয়, এবং প্রকাশের আগে কোনো ব্যক্তি এগুলো পর্যালোচনা করেন না।

মিথ

Saudi Arabia permanently ended all Israel normalization discussions in October 2024 and signed a comprehensive mutual-defense pact with Iran.

তথ্য

Saudi Arabia publicly conditioned formal relations with Israel, while officials separately met Iran in October 2024. No new Saudi-Iran mutual-defense pact was announced; the security cooperation accord cited in the 2023 restoration statement dates to 2001.

Social media posts combined two separate diplomatic tracks into one dramatic claim: that Saudi Arabia permanently ended every discussion of normalization with Israel in October 2024 and signed a comprehensive mutual-defense pact with Iran. The public record supports neither claim in that form. Saudi and Iranian officials met and discussed regional affairs, but the Saudi-Iran security agreement cited in official records dates to 2001, and the October 2024 visit produced no announced new defense treaty.

Saudi Arabia did state a firm condition for establishing diplomatic relations with Israel. In a September 18, 2024 address, Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman said the kingdom would not establish such relations without an independent state for Arabs and eastern Jerusalem as its capital. That was an official policy statement, but it did not announce that all contact or discussion had ended forever. The Saudi Gazette’s report on the Shoura Council speech documents the stated condition and date.

What happened in Riyadh

On October 9, Iranian Foreign Minister Abbas Araghchi visited Riyadh and met the Saudi crown prince and foreign minister. The Saudi Press Agency recorded the meeting, while The National’s report from Riyadh described talks on regional developments and the conflicts in Gaza and Lebanon. Iran’s foreign ministry spokesman characterized discussions between the two foreign ministers as constructive and said they reviewed bilateral relations. The account describes diplomacy and regional de-escalation efforts; it reports no treaty signing, mutual-defense commitment, or joint military pact.

The meeting followed the restoration of diplomatic relations announced by Saudi Arabia, Iran and China in March 2023. Their joint statement said the two states would reopen embassies and implement earlier bilateral agreements. It specifically identified a Security Cooperation Agreement signed on April 17, 2001, and a broader cooperation agreement signed in 1998. The joint statement hosted by the United Nations Peacemaker database makes the dates and scope clear: these were prior accords being implemented, not a comprehensive mutual-defense pact signed in October 2024.

Normalization remained a separate diplomatic track

Saudi policy toward Israel and Saudi-Iran rapprochement were distinct tracks. The September statement set a condition on formal Saudi-Israeli relations. It neither created a defense alliance with Tehran nor made the October meeting evidence of one. The Saudi-Iran discussions addressed bilateral ties and urgent regional tensions; the normalization question concerned possible relations between Saudi Arabia and Israel.

The Congressional Research Service’s August 2024 report helps establish the timeline for the separate U.S.-Saudi negotiations linked to possible normalization. It says Hamas’s October 7, 2023 attack and the ensuing conflict prompted a halt in U.S.-Saudi discussions about potential bilateral agreements connected to normalization, then records that U.S. officials and lawmakers had resumed engagement with Saudi counterparts from January 2024. The report therefore describes a disrupted and later resumed diplomatic process, not a permanent termination announced in October. See the Congressional Research Service report on possible U.S.-Saudi agreements and normalization.

That report also distinguishes a proposed U.S.-Saudi security arrangement from any Saudi-Iran agreement: officials had discussed a possible defense treaty and cooperation agreement between Washington and Riyadh. The existence of those negotiations does not establish a Saudi-Iran pact. Nor does restored Saudi-Iran diplomacy prove a military alliance. Cooperation between governments can involve diplomatic channels and crisis management without a mutual-defense obligation.

The claim’s core error is thus a merger of different facts and dates. Saudi Arabia had publicly conditioned normalization with Israel in September 2024. Saudi and Iranian officials met in Riyadh the following month. The security accord mentioned in the 2023 trilateral statement was signed in 2001, while the 2023 announcement restored diplomatic ties and addressed implementation of older agreements. None of these records supports the claim that Riyadh announced a permanent end to every normalization discussion and signed a new comprehensive defense pact with Tehran in October 2024.

তথ্যসূত্র

  1. 1
    Crown Prince: No ties with Israel without establishing Palestine Statehttps://saudigazette.com.sa/article/645623/SAUDI-ARABIA/Crown-Prince-No-ties-with-Israel-without-establishing-Palestine-Stateঅবিশ্বস্ত
  2. 2
    Iranian Foreign Minister meets Saudi Crown Prince as regional tension mountshttps://www.thenationalnews.com/news/mena/2024/10/09/irans-foreign-minister-visits-saudi-arabia-amid-rising-regional-tension/অবিশ্বস্ত
  3. 3
    Joint Trilateral Statement by China, Saudi Arabia and Iranhttps://peacemaker.un.org/sites/default/files/document/files/2024/05/joint20trilateral20statement20by20the20peoples20republic20of%20china20the%20kingdom20of%20saudi%20arabia.pdfঅবিশ্বস্ত
  4. 4

অ্যাক্সেসিবিলিটি সেটিংস

এই সেটিংস এই ডিভাইসে সংরক্ষিত রয়েছে।

প্রাকদর্শন

আপনার সুবিধামতো স্পষ্টভাবে পড়ুন

পড়ার সময় এই পৃষ্ঠাটি সমন্বয় করুন। উপকরণসমূহ দেখুন

টেক্সট
লেখার আকারপুরো সাইটে প্রযোজ্য।
রঙ ও বৈসাদৃশ্য
থিম
মোশন
অ্যানিমেশনডিভাইস মিলিয়ে নেওয়া আপনার মোশন কমানোর সেটিংস অনুসরণ করে।